TUESDAY, Dec. 17, 2013 (HealthDay News) -- For men having
prostate cancer surgery, the type of anesthesia doctors use might
make a difference in the odds of the cancer returning, a new study
Researchers found that of nearly 3,300 men who underwent
prostate cancer surgery, those who were given both general and
regional anesthesia had a lower risk of seeing their cancer
progress than men who received only general anesthesia.
Over a period of 15 years, about 5 percent of men given only
general anesthesia had their cancer recur in their bones or other
sites, the researchers said. That compared with 3 percent of men
who also received regional anesthesia, which typically meant a
spinal injection of the painkiller morphine, plus a numbing
None of that, however, proves that anesthesia choices directly
affect a prostate cancer patient's prognosis.
"We can't conclude from this that it's cause-and-effect," said senior researcher Dr. Juraj Sprung, an anesthesiologist at the Mayo Clinic in Rochester, Minn.
But, he said, one theory is that spinal painkillers -- like the
opioid morphine -- can make a difference because they curb
patients' need for opioid drugs after surgery. Those post-surgery
opioids, which affect the whole body, may decrease the immune
That's potentially important, Sprung said, because during
prostate cancer surgery, some cancer cells usually escape into the
bloodstream -- and a fully functioning immune response might be
needed to kill them off.
"If you avoid opioids after surgery, you may be increasing your ability to fight off these cancer cells," Sprung said.
The study, reported online Dec. 17 in the
British Journal of Anaesthesia, is not the first to see a
link between regional anesthesia and a lower risk of cancer
recurrence or progression. Some past studies have seen a similar
pattern in patients having surgery for breast, ovarian or colon
cancer. But those studies, like the current one, point only to a
correlation, not a cause-and-effect link, Sprung said.
Dr. David Samadi, chief of urology at Lenox Hill Hospital in New
York City, agreed. "We have to be very careful about how we
interpret these results," said Samadi, who was not involved in the
One important issue, he said, is that the men in this study all
had open surgery to remove their prostate gland.
But these days, the surgery is almost always done
laparoscopically -- a minimally invasive approach in which surgeons
make a few small incisions. In the United States, Samadi said, most
of these procedures are done with the aid of robotic "arms."
Compared with traditional open surgery, laparoscopic surgery is
quicker and causes less stress, blood loss and post-surgery pain,
Samadi said. And in his experience, he said, patients' need for
opioids after surgery is low.
Sprung agreed that it's not clear whether the current findings
extend to men having laparoscopic surgery.
The findings are based on the records of nearly 3,300 men who
had prostate cancer surgery between 1991 and 2005 at the Mayo
Clinic. Half had been given only general anesthesia, while the
other half had received regional anesthesia as well. In 83 percent
of the cases, that meant a spinal block containing morphine.
The researchers weighed other factors, such as the stage of the
cancer and whether a man received radiation or hormone therapy
after surgery. In the end, having general anesthesia alone was
linked to a nearly threefold higher risk of a cancer turning up in
distant sites in the body over the next 15 years.
Still, only 3 percent to 5 percent of the men had a cancer
recurrence. And, Samadi said, the risk is generally low with a
skilled surgeon. He suggested that patients be more concerned about
their surgeon's experience than the type of anesthesia.
Studies have found that prostate cancer patients treated by more
experienced surgeons tend to have a lower risk of recurrence,
Samadi said. They also have lower rates of lasting side effects,
such as erectile dysfunction and incontinence.
"It's not the robot," Samadi said. "It's the experience of the surgeon."
To prove that regional anesthesia directly affects cancer
patients' prognosis, "controlled" studies are needed, Sprung said.
That means randomly assigning some surgery patients to have general
anesthesia only, while others get regional anesthesia as well.
For now, Sprung said, the decision about whether to use a spinal
painkiller during surgery should be based on other factors, such as
its potential to limit post-surgery pain.
The American Cancer Society has more information on
prostate cancer surgery.
EBSCO Information Services is fully accredited by URAC. URAC is an independent, nonprofit health care accrediting organization dedicated to promoting health care quality through accreditation, certification and commendation.
Please be aware that this information is provided to supplement the care provided by your physician. It is neither intended nor implied to be a substitute for professional medical advice. CALL YOUR HEALTHCARE PROVIDER IMMEDIATELY IF YOU THINK YOU MAY HAVE A MEDICAL EMERGENCY. Always seek the advice of your physician or other qualified health provider prior to starting any new treatment or with any questions you may have regarding a medical condition.
Copyright © EBSCO Information Services. All rights reserved.