WEDNESDAY, May 25 (HealthDay News) -- Home-based exercise
managed by a physical therapist is just as effective at restoring
stroke patients' walking ability as a formal rehabilitation program
using a specialized treadmill, a new study indicates.
The results also defy conventional wisdom that stroke recovery
peaks at six months, demonstrating that patients who began
rehabilitation even six months after their stroke continued to
improve their walking for up to a year.
"It's a fantastic study, rigorously done," said Dr. Richard B. Libman, chief of vascular neurology at Long Island Jewish Medical Center in New Hyde Park, N.Y. "It's incredibly important . . . not to write patients off after a certain period of time has elapsed. Patients have the potential to improve way after the point where we thought they couldn't."
Researchers, calling it the largest stroke rehabilitation study
ever done in the United States, randomly assigned more than 400
stroke patients with moderate or severe walking impairments to one
of three study groups, two involving "locomotor" training and one
involving home exercise. The patients were recruited from inpatient
rehab facilities in California and Florida and had an average age
of 62. Slightly more than half were men.
All received 36 supervised, 90-minute sessions over a period of
12 to 16 weeks, in addition to usual care.
Those in "locomotor" training attended a formal rehabilitation
program where they used a treadmill while wearing a harness that
offered partial body-weight support. Following treadmill training,
they practiced walking. The early locomotor group started training
two months post-stroke; the other locomotor participants began six
months after their stroke. For the home-exercise group, a physical
therapist focused on enhancing patients' flexibility, range of
motion, strength and balance to improve walking ability, starting
two months post-stroke.
Study author Pamela Woods Duncan, a professor of community and
family medicine at Duke University School of Medicine, said she and
her team were surprised to find that patients in the home exercise
group did as well as those in locomotor training, which they
thought would produce superior results.
Indeed, at the end of one year, more than half (52 percent) of
all study participants had improved their walking ability, with
similar gains among all three groups. No differences were found
among those who had started treadmill training two months or six
months after their stroke.
"I think it's an extremely important study," Duncan said. "Those at home had equal outcomes . . . and fewer minor adverse events," such as dizziness and falls.
She and the other researchers also noted that the progressive
home exercise program involved less expensive equipment, less
training for physical therapists, fewer clinical staff members and
better patient compliance.
"Collectively, our results suggest that home exercise is a more pragmatic form of therapy with fewer risks," they wrote.
Libman called the study, published May 26 in the
New England Journal of Medicine,"practically revolutionary" for its potential to change standard stroke rehabilitation care.
"I think it's going to change the management of stroke, and third-party payers are going to be extremely interested in the results of the study," he said. "I think it will save a huge amount of money for the healthcare system and be psychologically and emotionally beneficial for patients."
Participants' improvement measurements were based on how well
they could walk independently by the end of the study. Severely
impaired patients were considered improved if they were able to
walk around the inside of a house, while patients already mobile at
home were considered improved if they progressed to walking
independently in the community.
Not only did the physical therapy patients recover walking
ability as well as the locomotor group, they were also less likely
to drop out of treatment -- 3 percent vs. 13 percent of the
Minor adverse events, mostly falls, were reported by about 56
percent of participants, with no significant differences among
groups. Patients who started locomotor therapy at two months and
were severely impaired, however, were more likely to report
Dr. Walter Koroshetz, deputy director of the U.S. National
Institute of Neurological Disorders and Stroke (NINDS), said few
studies have compared stroke therapies and provided evidence "in
such very rigorous fashion."
"So this is probably the tip of the iceberg," he said. "It's precedent-setting . . . with very practical results."
Funding for the study was provided by NINDS and the National
Center for Medical Rehabilitation Research.
To learn more about strokes, visit the
U.S. National Institute of Neurological Disorders and
Please be aware that this information is provided to supplement the care provided by your physician. It is neither intended nor implied to be a substitute for professional medical advice. CALL YOUR HEALTHCARE PROVIDER IMMEDIATELY IF YOU THINK YOU MAY HAVE A MEDICAL EMERGENCY. Always seek the advice of your physician or other qualified health provider prior to starting any new treatment or with any questions you may have regarding a medical condition.
Copyright © EBSCO Publishing. All rights reserved.