WEDNESDAY, Jan. 8, 2014 (HealthDay News) -- Children who are
critically ill after having heart surgery do not benefit from
having their blood sugar levels aggressively controlled, but some
kids with other life-threatening conditions might, a new study
Experts said the findings, reported in the Jan. 9 issue of the
New England Journal of Medicine, suggest that critically ill
children should not routinely have their blood sugar tightly
But doctors might consider it for kids who have landed in the
intensive-care unit for reasons other than heart surgery, said
study author Dr. Duncan Macrae. Macrae's team found that those
children had a shorter hospital stay when they received insulin
infusions to keep their blood sugar within normal range.
People who are critically ill or injured often develop very high
blood sugar levels -- what doctors call hyperglycemia. The
condition is a response to stress and injury, said Macrae, a
consultant in pediatric intensive care at the Royal Brompton and
Harefield NHS Foundation Trust in London.
In the past, doctors did not aggressively treat hyperglycemia in
critically ill patients, thinking it was natural and even helpful,
Macrae said. But in 2001, a study of severely ill adults found that
getting blood sugar levels down to normal decreased patients' risk
of dying or developing certain complications, such as kidney
Not all studies since have found a benefit, however, and there's
been much less known about the effects in children.
Doctors aren't sure that high blood sugar itself directly
increases critically ill patients' risk, said Dr. Michael Agus, of
Boston Children's Hospital, who wrote an editorial published with
"Hyperglycemia may merely be indicative of severe physiological stress," and not necessarily the cause of complications, Agus said.
The only way to figure it all out, Agus said, is to do clinical
trials, like the current one.
For the study, Macrae's team focused on nearly 1,400 children
being treated in ICUs at 13 different hospitals in England. Sixty
percent had undergone heart surgery, while the rest had landed in
the ICU for other reasons, such as a severe head injury or blood
Roughly half of the children were randomly assigned to
"conventional" blood sugar control, which involved infusions of
insulin only when sugar levels went above a certain level. The
other children received tight blood sugar control, with insulin
infusions that were continuously adjusted to keep sugar levels in
the normal range.
In the end, the intensive therapy did not improve children's
survival odds: 5 percent of kids in each group died within 30
But when the researchers dug deeper, they found that among
children who had not undergone heart surgery, those on tight blood
sugar control got out of the hospital faster -- two weeks sooner,
Agus suggested a potential explanation for the difference
between the two groups: Children not having heart surgery seemed to
be more critically ill, and might have had more to gain from tight
blood sugar control, he said.
Children having heart surgery are in fairly stable condition
going in, and the course of their recovery is more predictable,
Agus said. But children who land in the ICU because of accidents or
a sudden illness are generally in less stable condition.
Macrae said the reasons for the shorter hospital stay are not
clear. But the findings suggest that, for children who have not had
heart surgery, doctors should consider tight blood sugar control,
Agus was more cautious. He said the best course for those
critically ill kids "remains an open question," and ongoing studies
should help find an answer.
The major risk from tight blood sugar control is hypoglycemia,
in which blood sugar levels drop too low, Macrae said.
Hypoglycemia can also be dangerous, potentially causing
complications such as seizures and brain damage. In this study, 7
percent of children on tight blood sugar control developed severe
hypoglycemia, versus just 1.5 percent in the comparison group.
Agus said doctors need to feel confident that the benefits of
intensive insulin therapy outweigh the risks of lowering blood
sugar too much.
More broadly, he said the new trial underscores the importance
of studying treatments in children, rather than relying on results
in adults. "It would be a big mistake to simply take findings in
adults and apply them to all critically ill children," Agus
As this study shows, even different groups of children might
respond differently to a therapy, he said.
The Nemours Foundation has more on
pediatric intensive care.
Please be aware that this information is provided to supplement the care provided by your physician. It is neither intended nor implied to be a substitute for professional medical advice. CALL YOUR HEALTHCARE PROVIDER IMMEDIATELY IF YOU THINK YOU MAY HAVE A MEDICAL EMERGENCY. Always seek the advice of your physician or other qualified health provider prior to starting any new treatment or with any questions you may have regarding a medical condition.
Copyright © EBSCO Publishing. All rights reserved.