Breast Cancer
Screening Trial Shows Digital Mammogram Benefits
Behind the Cancer Headlines®
A landmark breast cancer screening trial shows that digital mammography detected more cancers – up to 28 percent more – than screen film mammography in women 50 and younger, premenopausal and perimenopausal women, and women with dense breasts.
However, the trial, conducted by the
With 49,528 women enrolled at 33 clinical sites, the trial is one of the largest breast cancer screening studies ever performed. Brown’s Center for Statistical Sciences developed the study’s statistical design and analyzed the results.
“The data show that digital mammography is, on average, as good at detecting breast cancer as film mammography – and in some important subgroups of women, digital performs even better,” said Constantine Gatsonis, network statistician for ACRIN, professor of community health and applied mathematics at Brown, and an author of the New England Journal article.
Because of its size and rigor, Gatsonis said, the study provides some of the best data gathered on the diagnostic accuracy of mammograms. “Neither film nor digital mammography is able to catch every cancer,” Gatsonis said. “So this study data can be used to develop and improve mammography in the coming years. And that is good news for women’s health.”
The primary aim of the trial, dubbed the Digital Mammographic Imaging Screening Trial (DMIST), was to compare the diagnostic performance of digital and film mammography.
Women enrolled in the trial had no signs of breast cancer. Volunteers of all ages – the median age was 54 – took part. Each woman was given both digital and film screenings. Then they were randomized so that half had the digital exam first, the other half had the film exam first. Two different radiologists independently interpreted the mammograms.
Doctors determined participants’ breast cancer status through follow-up mammography or available biopsy results. Biopsy information was available within 15 months of study entry. Mammograms were taken 10 months or later after study entry.
Barbara Schepps, M.D., oversaw
DMIST at Rhode Island Hospital (RIH), a major trauma center for southeastern
A radiologist and director of the Anne C. Pappas Center for Breast Imaging at RIH, Schepps said, “With this new information, we are going to strive to convert all our units to digital as soon as possible. While the study doesn’t show that digital mammography benefits all women, it clearly makes a difference for younger women, a population that is known to be difficult to examine because they tend to have denser breasts.
“The important message is that all women get screened
annually – whether with digital or conventional mammography,” said Schepps, a clinical professor at
SOURCES:
New England Journal of
Medicine, online edition,